Holiday Cookies Box 2025

Creating a Christmas Cookie Gift Box is one of the best ways to share holiday cheer with your friends and family. Baking Christmas cookies is a tradition I look forward to every year. Once the Gingerbread, Christmas Sugar Cookies, and homemade Almond Roca are in the kitchen, it finally feels like Christmas. I bake a wide variety of cookies for entertaining and assembling Christmas cookie boxes. Using make-ahead recipes keeps the process so much easier. Every recipe I’m sharing here freezes well, either as dough or fully baked – so you can prepare all eight Christmas cookie recipes in advance and build a beautiful, homemade holiday cookie box when you’re ready.

Homemade cookies make a great Christmas gifts, but really, a cookie box is a great gift any time of year. I don’t know too many people who only appreciate cookies at Christmas. I’d be over the moon if someone gifted me a homemade box of cookies in March or June.

Why You Will Love This Years Boxed Holiday Cookies

• A mix of classic and festive favorites. From Christmas sugar cookies and gingerbread to chocolate peppermint cookies and almond bark, this box brings together the best flavors of the season.
• Perfect balance of textures. Crisp shortbread, airy meringue Christmas trees, and crunchy Almond Roca – there’s something for every cookie lover.
• Beautiful and gift ready. With colorful decorations, shaped cookies, and a mix of candies and treats, this box looks as good as it tastes.
• Make-ahead friendly recipes. Almost every treat here can be frozen as dough or baked cookies, so you can prep at your own pace.
• Ideal for gifting. This collection travels well and stays fresh, making it perfect for neighbors, teachers, hosts, or family gatherings.
• Kid-approved favorites. Sugar cookies, gingerbread men, and meringue trees are always popular with kids and fun to decorate together.
• Great variety in every bite. Eight different treats mean no one gets bored – your holiday cookie box feels abundant, thoughtful, and homemade. If eight recipes seems like too much, you can make as many or as few as you want.
• Perfect for entertaining. Keep a box in the freezer to bring out when guests pop by or serve alongside hot chocolate or coffee.
• Simple ingredients, big flavor. Classic pantry staples come together to create a cookie box that feels nostalgic, cozy, and completely homemade.

What to Keep in Mind When Creating a Box of Holiday Cookies

First off you need to decide how many people you will be making boxes for. Next, how big of a box do you want to gift to each person, and how many cookies and candies you will need for each box. When choosing which type of cookies to include in a cookie box, you want to make sure you have a variety of textures, flavors, shapes, and colors. You also want to make sure your cookies are shelf stable at room temperature. If you want to add something that goes off quickly, then you will want to make it the day you gift the box.

I like to gift homemade cookies, but you can also mix in some store bought cookies too. When it comes to small candies that can be used to fill in little crevices, store bought is often easier. Candy canes make a great addition for example.

Finding an appropriate box can be a challenge. Just keep in mind you want something sturdy that can hold a bit of weight. The dollar store often has Christmas cookie tins and boxes around the holidays, and Michaels has neutral photo boxes that are a suitable size (think shoe box size). You can always wrap the outside with gift wrap and ribbon to turn a boring old box into something more festive.

This year I was lucky. My husband put together this wooden cookie box for me out of leftover wood he had. I love it!

Recipes I Used This Season in my Christmas Cookie Gift Box

The recipes I chose this year for my holiday cookies box are great for making ahead of time. They include:

Christmas Sugar Cookies – Sugar cookies are one of my all time favorites. The recipe is so versatile as it can make cookies for any occasion, just swap out the cookie cutter shapes and you go from Christmas stockings, to Valentine’s hearts! And the sweet vanilla flavor is to die for.

Gingerbread Cookies – Another Christmas time classic. I love this soft and chewy recipe because I’ve toned the spices and left out the cloves, which keeps the flavor kid friendly while still delivering that classic gingerbread taste.

Chocolate Peppermint Cookies – Crushed candy canes sprinkled on peppermint flavored chocolate cookies just screams holiday flavor. I dip them in white chocolate for extra visual appeal and an even more indulgent flavor.

Shortbread Cookies – another classic cookie that stands the test of time. Cookies that keep coming back year after year – you know they are good! This is a must in our house as it is my husband’s favorite.

Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies – This buttery dough cookie stands out in your cookie box with it’s bright ruby red jam filling. You can mix things up by using different colored/flavored jam as well.

Non-Cookie Treats for the Cookie Box

Christmas Tree Meringues – These light airy sweet confections are a perfect textural contrast to the cookies. They are straightforward to make and I use up leftover egg whites that I have stored in the freezer over the months. Making custard and pudding can you leave you with a lot of egg whites you don’t know what to do with. Save them in the freezer and make these cute little trees or meringue kisses. If you live somewhere with high humidity these can become sticky. But once they come out of the oven and are cool, they freeze well until you are ready to use them.

Almond Roca – These are a crowd favorite and do not last long on a cookie plate. Crunchy and sweet – they are the Christmas candy in high demand. They also help to fill in little crevices in your cookie box. Their finely chopped almond coating also adds a textural change to the other treats in the box.

Almond Bark – Almost everyone loves chocolate! This recipe is super easy and only requires two ingredients, but the outcome is amazing! Broken into rustic shards they offer something different in your cookie box. You can make dark, white, or milk chocolate almond bark to please everyone’s tastes.

Planning Your Baking In Advance

I probably don’t have to point this out, but it would be very time consuming to try to bake all these cookies in one day. But if you do, let me know how it goes and how long it took! I like to plan out which cookies I’m going to bake in advance, and if I’m going to freeze them decorated or undecorated. The following table can help you make a schedule of which cookies you are going to make first, will you freeze the dough until later, or freeze the final cookie? It’s good to have a schedule set up in advance so you aren’t stressed at the last minute.

Cookie	Dough Freezes?	Cookie Freezes?
Christmas Sugar Cookies	Yes	Yes, with or without royal icing and sprinkles
Shortbread Cookies	Yes	Yes, with or without decorations
Gingerbread Cookies	Yes	Yes, with or without royal icing and sprinkles/decorations
Almond Roca	No	Yes
Almond Bark	No	No
Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies	Yes	Yes, but glaze should be added the day before you will put the box together. The jam can discolor the glaze over time. Or skip glazing all together.
Chocolate Peppermint Cookies	Yes	Yes, but dipping in white chocolate and sprinkling of candy cane should be done the day of boxing the cookies as candy canes get soft and sticky over time.
Christmas Tree Meringues	No	Yes, freezes well in a zipper top bag.

Putting Together Your Christmas Cookie Gift Box

To begin with, its a good idea to line the bottom of the box with parchment or wax paper. You may want to also cut pieces to of parchment or wax paper to go between layers of sticky cookies if you are using. This cookie box didn’t need wax paper layers.

To keep your cookie box visually appealing, decide which cookies can be stacked and tied with a colorful ribbon or string. Some cookies look great displayed on their sides, adding height and texture. I usually place the most eye-catching stack in the center as a focal point. Next, fill in your corners with other cookie stacks, and then start filling the spots in between with the rest of the cookies. Try to not have two types of similar cookies right next to each other. If you don’t have time to make 8 different types of cookies, you can make fewer recipes and just double or triple them to fill your box. One of the great things about creating your own cookie gift box is you get to have full creative control on what’s going in.

Once all the cookies are in, I try to fill empty spaces with candies, shredded color paper (available at dollar and craft stores), and even tiny Christmas ornaments to give the box a festive look.

Enjoy designing your Holiday Cookie Box – make it your own and have fun with it. But be prepared for your friends, family, and neighbors requesting cookie boxes next year!

How to Prepare a Holiday Cookies Box for Mailing?

Mailing cookies is a great way to send love and holiday cheer! Think of all those kids in December at college and university studying like mad in December. What a treat to have a box of holiday cookies sitting in their dorm room to keep them going and reminding them that Christmas is almost here!

For mailing, make sure you wrap each stack of cookies in plastic wrap to help keep them fresh. Then place in the box. It’s also important to make sure the cookies are super snug, if there is space for them to move around, they will become cookie crumbs before they make it to their destination. So you can fill any empty space with balled up Christmas paper, shredded colored paper, Styrofoam peanuts if you have some laying around and you don’t know what to do with them, or balled up newspaper if you are in a pinch. Remember all your cookies are wrapped in plastic wrap so they won’t pick up smells from the newspaper etc. Make sure you have a lid for your box.

Depending on how strong your box is, you will probably need to put this cookie box in another sturdy box and fill any space with balled up newspaper or leftover styrofoam peanuts. Who knows how many jostles and bumps the box is going to take on its journey. Once all snug, wrap the box in Kraft paper, or other mailing paper, and you are ready to go.

I’m so excited for you and your Holiday Cookies Box! Let me know how it turned out for you by leaving a comment or tagging me on social media.

Follow Me On Social Media

• Facebook
• Pinterest
• Instagram
• YouTube

If You Liked This Christmas Cookie Box Recipe…

If you liked this recipe, please consider rating the recipe and leaving a comment below – I love to hear how people get on with my recipes and I truly make an effort to respond to everyone who takes the time to comment. Other recipes you might enjoy include: